Jan 3, 2017

Preventing corruption in India


New amendments have been proposed to the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988 (PCA). The amendments which were first proposed in 2013 have been revived with the aim of protecting honest government officials and encouraging a favorable decision making environment. The amendments have been approved by Cabinet as well as Rajya Sabha.

This is specially highlighted after Harish Gupta, a former secretary in coal ministry was summoned by courts in the alleged Coal Scam which came to light under the previous United Progressive Alliance government. According to newspaper reports, Gupta's case has received more attention because he is recognized as an officer of impeccable professional integrity by his peers. It was also reported that Gupta confessed 'wrongdoing' because he did not have patience and resources to face a trial. 

An investigator’s take

PaGaLGuY spoke to a retired officer of Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) who has worked in the Anti-Corruption branch of the agency to get a better perspective on the issue. He said, “The proposed amendments narrow down the existing definition of corruption. Words like ‘illicit enrichment, one’s control and disproportionate assets are terms that include all aspects needed for investigating corruption charges.” He further added, “A balance has to be maintained between punishing a corrupt public servant and giving an honest one an opportunity to explain his side. This balance is being maintained here.”

To make things more clear, the retired official quoted former Prime Minister Manmohan Singh who once said that many decisions are taken in an atmosphere of uncertainty, when not all facts are known. So, in hindsight these decisions may appear different. The officer agreed that the provision of making permission compulsory to initiate an inquiry for officials above the rank of Joint Secretary acts more as a hurdle. This is because such permissions are delayed or worse never given due to the proximity of these officers to political executives. So, such a provision end up being a hindrance for investigators. 

“The burden to prove a case better lie with the investigator”, said the officer. “A law should not lead to unnecessary hounding of government servants or create an atmosphere of fear/witch-hunting. Such an environment will be detrimental to overall progress of the country”, the official said referring to critics opposing the amendments.

Proposed amendments and key issues 

  • Criminal misconduct to only cover misappropriation of property and possession of disproportionate assets to income. Proving intention behind misappropriation rests with investigating agency. Corruption in not always in cash but also in kind. By not considering favors in kind, a large loophole is being left unattended. Typically, this would include favors shown in return for better postings, post-retirement benefits among others which are punishable under the current law. To reinforce this, section 13 (1)(d) now reads that benefits which are other than economic are not punishable.
  • Section 13 (1)(d)- the only section in the act which allows investigation of government officials has been removed.
  • Bribe-giver and bribe-taker equally liable for punishment. Bribe can be given under collusion or coercion. It was suggested by Law Commission that if bribe giver is under coercion, he/she should not be punished as it would deter people from lodging a complaint. But this has been ignored as is evident.
  • Single Directive- a government order passed in 2003 which made prior sanction compulsory to prosecute senior officials (rank of Joint Secretary and above) has made a comeback. This means prior sanction to prosecute serving government officials compulsory. The Single Directive was declared illegal in Vineet Narain Case of 1997 by the Supreme Court (SC). It made a comeback in 2003 as a provision of law and it continued till 2014. In 2014, SC declared it as unconstitutional. But powerful bureaucracy seems to attempt to make this immunity legal, a third time.
It is clear from this debate that, corruption as a social malaise does not occur in isolation. It is part of the society and will require an effort which involves all stakeholders like government, police, civil society and most importantly citizens.

No comments:

Post a Comment

Labels

7th CPC (627) A Boon or Bane (1) Aadhaar Card (32) Accounts Department (4) ACR (2) Additional Allowances (1) Additional Secretaries (1) Advance (13) Advantage Employees (1) Advertisements (1) Age Relaxation (1) AIBEA (1) AIBOA (1) AICPIN (12) AIPAEA (1) Air Force (2) Air Ticket (2) AIRF (7) AITUC (1) Allowances (167) Annual Income (2) Anomalies (18) APARs (4) ARC (1) Armed Forces (10) Armed Forces Hospitals (1) Army Pay Commission (9) Arrears (25) Asset Declaration (11) ATM (2) Attendance (1) Axis Bank (1) Bank Employees Salary (16) Bank Employees Strike (13) Bank Pensioners (1) Banking (5) Banks (11) Bechmark (1) Bengaluru (1) Bharat Ratna (1) Bihar News (1) Birth / Death Certificate (1) Black Day (1) Black Money (2) Bonus (58) BPMS (11) BSNL (16) Budget (36) Bunching (10) Cabinet Approval (7) Cadre Review (18) Canteens (2) CAPF (1) Cash Transactions (3) Cashless State (2) Cashless Transaction (1) Caste (1) CASTE CERTIFICATE (1) Casual Labour (13) CAT (5) CBDT (2) CBI (2) CBSE (3) CCAS Cadre (1) CCS Rules (21) Central Armed Forces (1) Central Civil Pension (1) Central Excise Officers (2) Central Government Employees (120) Central Government Examination (3) Central Secretariat (2) Certificate (2) CGA Organization (1) CGEGIS (7) CGHS (28) CGHS Contribution (4) CGHS Hospitals (6) Charge Sheet (1) Chief Justice (1) Child Care Leave (7) Children Education Allowance (15) CITU (1) Civil Servant (2) Clarifications (27) Commemorative Coin (1) Commutation (1) Comparison (7) Compassionate Appointment (5) Compulsory Retirement (1) Computer Advance (3) Conduct Rules (1) Confederation (14) Consumer Price Index (3) Contract Labour (6) Corruption (3) Court Orders (1) CPGRAMS (1) CPI (1) CPMA (1) CPSE (3) Credit Card (2) CSD Chennai (2) CTET (1) CTU (1) Customs (1) CVC (1) da (1) DA Merger (3) DA News & Orders (105) DA Orders (12) Dearness Relief (12) Death Benefits (3) Death Claim (1) Debit Card (4) Defence (39) Delay Salary Hike (6) Demonetisation (28) Dental Clinic (1) DEPARTMENT OF EXPENDITURE (3) Department of Personnel & Training (6) Department of Posts (15) Department of Revenue (2) Department of Telecommunication (2) Deposit Scheme (1) Deputation (7) Dharna (2) Digital India (3) Digital Payment (19) Direct Benefit Transfer Scheme (2) Directorate of Estates (2) Disability Pension (6) Disabled person (6) Disadvantages (2) Discontinuation of Interview (1) DOP Orders (1) DoPT (70) Dress Allowances (1) e-PPO (1) e-Service Book (1) Earned Leave (1) ECHS (1) ECHS Smart Card (1) EFPO (1) Election 2016 (2) Election 2019 (1) Election Holiday (9) Employment News (15) Empowered Committee (27) Entry Level Pay (2) EPF (14) EPFO (15) Equal Work Equal Pay (2) ESIC (2) Ex-India Leave (1) Ex-Servicemen (15) Expectations (1) Expenses (1) Facebook (2) Fake News (3) Family Pension (13) Family Planning Allowance (1) FAQ (5) Federations (2) Finance Ministry (36) Financial Impact (7) Fire Engine driver (1) Fitment Factor (15) Fixed Medical Allowances (1) Foreign Tour (1) Forest Protection (1) Fraud Cases (1) Fund for Pay Commission (2) Fund Transfer (1) GAAR (1) Gas Subsidy (1) Gazette Notification (20) GDP (1) GDS (28) GeM Portal (1) General (97) Global Economy (1) Gold Deposit (2) Gold Rate (1) Governance (1) Government Doctors (12) Government Jobs (20) Government of India (1) Government Offices (2) Government Policies (1) Government Service (2) GPF (16) GPRA (1) Grade Pay (28) Gratuity (11) Greetings (1) Gross Pay (1) Group A Officers (2) Group B and C (3) Group D (1) GST (18) Guidelines (5) Gujarat Government (1) Hackers (1) HBA (1) HDFC (1) Health Camp (1) High Court (4) High Level Committee (4) High lights on 7th Pay commission (1) Higher Education (1) Higher Grade Pay (2) Holiday Homes (2) Holidays (13) Home Minister (1) Hospitality (1) House Building Advance (2) HRA (43) HRD Ministry (1) IAS (9) Immovable Property Return (1) Implementation (142) Incentive (6) income (1) Income Tax (90) Increment (31) India Post (3) Indian Banks Association (1) Indian Economy (4) Indian Institute of Legal Metrology (1) Indian Navy (3) Indian Rupees (12) Injustice (1) Insurance (3) Intellectual Property (1) Interest Rate (4) Interim Relief (5) Invest Money (6) IoFS (1) IPR (2) IPS (7) IRCTC (4) IRTSA (1) IT Department Officials (1) J&K (5) Jan Dhan Accounts (2) JCM (17) Jeevan Pramaan (2) Job Portal (2) Joint declaration form (1) Joint Secretary (1) Karnataka (1) Kendriya Vidyalaya (17) Kendriya Vihar (1) Kerala Pay Commission (6) Krishi Kalyan cess (1) KVS (5) KYC (1) Lay off (1) LDC Clerk (1) Leave (7) LED (1) Level of Rank (2) Level Rank (1) LIC (5) Life Certificate for Pensioners (2) Loan (4) Loco Inspectors (1) Lok Sabha (25) Lokpal and Lokayuktas (4) LPG (3) LPG Subsidy (3) LTC (34) MACP (46) Maharashtra Government (1) Make in India (1) Maternity Leave (19) Matrix Calculator (3) Matrix Table (9) Maximum wage (3) Medical Allowances (3) Medical Examination (1) Medical Reimbursement (3) Memorandum (1) Military Forces (5) Minimum Wage (48) Ministry of Health & Family Welfare (1) Ministry of Home Affairs (2) Ministry of Labour & Employment (1) Ministry of Personnel (1) Ministry of Urban Development (2) Ministry of Women and Child Development (1) MLCs (1) MP Salaries (10) MTNL (1) MTS (3) Mutual Transfer (1) National Anthem (1) National Pension Scheme (9) National Sports Awards (1) NEET (2) Net Pay (1) New Pension Scheme (11) NFIR Union (34) NFS (1) Night Duty Allowance (1) NJCA (43) NMC (4) NOC (2) Non Payment of Salary (1) Non Practicing Allowance (2) Not Effective (1) Notification (8) NPS (45) OBC (5) Officiating Allowances (3) Old Pension Scheme (1) Olympics (1) OROP (50) OTA (4) Overtime Allowance (4) PAN (8) Paramilitary (1) Parliament March (1) Passport (3) Pay and Allowances (1) Pay Band (6) Pay Commission (425) Pay Commission Deffered (1) Pay Commission News (386) Pay Commission Orders (1) Pay Commission Report (23) Pay Commission Report Submission (8) Pay Commission Revealed (1) Pay Fixation (22) Pay Matrix (24) Pay Revision (12) Pay Scale (4) Payment Bank (6) Payment of Salary (9) Pension (189) Pensioner Portal (3) Pensioners Federations (1) Performance Based (3) Periodical Review (1) Permanent Commission (1) Petrol (1) PF deduction (1) PF Withdrawal (1) PFMS (1) PFRDA (11) PG Portal (1) PIB (25) PLB Bonus (5) PMGKD Scheme (1) PMO (1) POBR (1) Political Parties (1) POSB Rate of Interest (2) Post Graduate (1) Post Offices (2) Postal JCA (3) Postmen Staffs (1) PPF (4) Pre-Retirement (4) President (1) President Salary (1) Private School (2) Promote Hindi (1) Promotion (12) Protest Programme (2) Provident Fund (2) Provisional Certificate (1) Public Grievances (1) PWD (1) Rail Fare (4) Railway (217) Railway Tatkal (2) Rajya Sabha (8) RBI (47) Re-Employment (2) Ready Reckoner (37) Recommendations (52) Recovery (1) Recruitment (29) Reservation (1) Reservation Chart (1) Resignation (1) Retirement (26) Retirement Age (18) Review Committee (3) Revised Pay Rules 2016 (12) Revision of Pension (8) RIO Olympic 2016 (7) Road Toll Tax (1) Rotational Transfer (2) RTI (13) Rupees (1) SAARC (1) Salaries of MLAs (2) Salary (1) Salary Advance (4) Salary Hike in Pay Commission (38) Savings (4) SBI (13) SC/ST Employees (5) Scholarship (1) SCOVA (9) Secretariat (3) Secretaries (1) Senior Citizen (2) Seniority (1) Service Charges (2) Service Tax (4) Seventh Pay Commission Calculator (27) Sexual Harassment (12) Small Savings (4) Smart Cities (1) Social Media (2) SPARROW (1) Spcial Casual Leave (1) Special Benefits (2) Special Casual Leave (1) Sports (10) SSC (9) Standard Operating Procedure (1) State Pay Commission (52) strike (117) Study Leave (1) Supreme Court (8) Survey (1) Suspension (1) Swachh Bharat Campaign (4) TA (1) TA allowances (2) Take Home (1) Tamil Nadu (4) Tax Payers (3) TDS (6) Teacher (2) Telangana Government (2) Tour Allowance (1) Tourism (1) Trade Union (9) Transport Allowance (2) Travelling Allowances (8) UIDAI (1) under Performers (1) Union News (42) UPSC (4) Uttar Pradesh (1) Vacant Posts (1) Vacation (1) Vacation Department (1) Vigilance (4) VRS (3) Wage Hike (6) Welfare (4) West Bengal (5) Whatsapp (1) Wholesale Price Index (1) Working Hours (1) Workshop (2) World Cup (1) WOS Currency Notes (10)